Maryland Drunk Driving Lawyer           Jack I Hyatt             410 - 486 - 1800

Image showing a field sobriety test for DWI, court room, and supreme court


Home
Frequently Asked  Questions
Attorney Credentials
Drunk Driving Information
Testimonials
Contact Us
Links
Cities and Towns we Serve

 
Driving Directions:



 

Cities and Towns we Serve

DuiData2

index

What is the State's Burden of Proof?

In relationship to the burden of proof, the manner in which the lawyer communicates (and educates) just how high "beyond a reasonable doubt" is to a jury, often is the difference in a conviction versus being found not guilty of the drunk driving charge. It is not necessarily what the lawyer says; rather, it is the manner in which he says it. If the jury does not think the burden is very high, it will take less evidence (and less convincing from the prosecutor) to convict you. One reason why I am so successful in trial is my ability to have the jurors realize just how high a burden "beyond a reasonable doubt" is.

The following is, in a nutshell, how I go about explaining beyond a reasonable doubt to jurors, and as you can tell, it is a very high burden.

The State of Maryland must prove your guilt "beyond a reasonable doubt", which is the highest burden of proof in the justice system. It is not defined, but we do how other burdens of proof have been described.

The lowest burden of proof is called probable cause. Have you ever received a ticket that you disagreed with (as opposed to just not liking the fact you received the ticket)? This level of proof is less then a 50-50 chance that you violated the law, but is all the officer needs to write you a ticket, or to arrest you.

The next highest burden of proof is called a preponderance of the evidence. This amount of proof occurs in civil courtrooms where people are suing each other for money. A preponderance of the evidence is proof amounting to you being 51% correct.

The next highest burden of proof is called clear and convincing evidence. This burden applies to child custody cases. This amount of proof will cause a juror to have a "firm belief" in the matter to be proved. To let the jury understand just how high this burden is, I find two women on the jury panel. I then will ask "Ms. Jones, I want you to look over at Ms. Smith sitting next to you. She has children. How much evidence do you think the government would have to have before they could take Ms. Smiths' children away from her?" I ask several other jurors the same question. I then ask "Ms. Jones, how much evidence would the government have to have to take your kids away from you?" I record their answers and will use them in my final argument. Jurors have told me that the amount of evidence the government would need to take children away would have ranged from "a whole lot," "tons," "beyond a shadow of a doubt," to "I don't think the government could ever have enough to take my kids away!"

Beyond a Reasonable Doubt is the highest burden of proof. Although not defined, it is a much higher burden the clear and convincing evidence. Why? Your freedom is on the line! A jury must have more then "tons" of evidence that you were intoxicated before they could find you guilty. This is a very simple, yet extremely convincing manner of making a jury understand just how much evidence is required before they can convict a person, thus branding them a criminal for the rest of their life.

Simply put, if a juror has a single doubt, based on reason, as to a person being intoxicated, they must follow the law and find them not guilty.

What Are Field Sobriety Tests?

Field Sobriety Tests (FST's) are psychophysical tests used to assess a person's physical and/or mental impairment. They focus on the abilities needed for safe driving. Most of the more reliable psychophysical tests are known as "divided attention" tasks. They require a person to concentrate on more then one task at the same time.

To safely drive a car, a person needs to be able to simultaneously control steering, breaking, and acceleration; react to constantly changing driving environment; and perform many other tasks. Alcohol affects one's ability to adequately divide attention, thus causing drivers to concentrate on more difficult tasks while ignoring simpler ones (i.e. ignore a traffic signal while concentrating on one's speed). Even if impaired, most people can successfully concentrate on a single task fairly well, but when impaired, most drivers cannot successfully divide their attention between multiple tasks at once.

Divided attention tasks are designed to evaluate mental and physical capabilities a person needs to safely drive a car. They include information processing; short-term memory; judgment and decision making; balance; steady, sure reactions; clear vision; small muscle control; and coordination of limbs. A good FST will combine any two or more of these capabilities simultaneously. A test must also be reasonably simple for the average non-intoxicated person to perform.

The most common FST's used by the police include the three standardized tests consisting of the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus tests, Walk & Turn test, and the One Leg Stand test. These three tests have been validated as reliable indicators of intoxication, although they are not 100% accurate. Other commonly used, but non-standardized, tests include counting backwards, saying the alphabet (or a portion of it), finger count, and the stationary balance (Rhomberg) tests.

In reference to the three standardized FST's, the government has admitted, and it is printed in the police officers DWI manual, that "IT IS NECESSARY TO EMPHASIZE THIS VALIDATION ONLY APPLIES WHEN: THE TESTS ARE ADMINISTERED IN THE PRESCRIBED STANDARED MANNER; THE STANDARDIZED CLUES ARE USED TO ASSESS THE SUSPECTS PERFORMANCE; THE STANDARDIZED CRITERIA ARE EMPLOYED TO INTERPRET THAT PERFORMANCE. IF ANY ONE OF THE STANDARDIZED FIELD SOBRITY TEST ELEMENTS IS CHANGED, THE VALIDITY IS COMPRAMISED."

Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN)

This test refers to the involuntary jerking of the eye as it gazes to the side. When this occurs, the person is unaware of the jerking, and cannot control it. This involuntary jerking becomes noticeable as persons' blood alcohol increases. This is the most reliable of the FST's. However, nystagmus is a natural, normal phenomenon. Alcohol and certain drugs do not cause this phenomenon.

When the HGN test is administered, the officer hold a stimulus (usually a pen) 12-15 inches in front of you eyes and asks you to follow the stimulus with your eyes, without moving your head. The officer will always start with the left eye and they are looking for 3 specific clues:

1. Lack of Smooth Pursuit:

As the eye moves from side to side, does it move smoothly or does it noticeably jerk (bounce)? The jerking is similar to how windshield wipers jerk across a dry windshield. There is a standardized pace the officer is to have the eyes move side to side. From the center of the face, they are to move the eye all the way out to the side in approximately 2 seconds, then 2 seconds back to center, approximately 2 seconds to the other side, and 2 seconds back to center. They are to repeat the procedure. If they have the eyes move too fast, not only are they performing the test improperly, the government has admitted tha

2. Distinct Nystagmus at Maximum Deviation: When the eye moves as far to the side as possible and is kept in that position for several seconds, is there distinct jerking (bouncing) of the eye. The eye is to be moved all the way to the side, and kept there a minimum of 4 seconds. Interestingly enough, some people exhibit slight jerking of the eye at maximum deviation even when unimpaired! Also, if the eye is moved to the side too quickly, this may cause the nystagmus.

3. Onset of Nystagmus Prior To 45 Degrees: As the eye moves towards the side, does it start to jerk (bounce) before it reaches a 45-degree angle? When moving the eye out to 45-degree's, the movement of the eye should take approximately 4 seconds to reach 45-degrees. It is important to take the full 4 seconds when checking for onset. If the stimulus is moved too fast, the officer could take your eye beyond 45 degrees, or if the eye is moved to 45-degrees too quickly, th

The maximum number of clues in each eye is 3, for a total of 6 clues. The original research has shown that if 4 or more clues are present, the person is intoxicated. This test has been shown to be accurate 77% of the time; therefore, it is inaccurate 23% of the time!

DuiData

Allegany County 

Barton 
Corriganville
Cresaptown
Cumberland
Eckhart Mines
Ellerslie 
Flintstone 
Frostburg
LaVale
Little Orleans

 

Lonaconing
Luke
Midland
Midlothian
Mount Savage
Oldtown
Pinto
Rawlings
Spring Gap
Westernport

Anne Arundel County  

Annapolis
Arnold 
Brooklyn Park 
Cape Saint Claire
Churchton
Crofton 
Crownsville 
Davidsonville 
Deale 
Edgewater 
Ferndale 
Friendship 
Galesville 
Gambrills 
Gibson Island 
Glen Burnie
Hanover

 

Harwood 
Linthicum 
Linthicum Heights 
Lothian 
Mayo 
Millersville 
Odenton 
Pasadena 
Riva 
Riviera Beach 
Severn 
Severna Park 
Shady Side 
Sherwood Forest 
Tracys Landing 
West River

Baltimore City  

Baltimore County  

Baldwin 
Boring 
Bradshaw 
Brooklandville 
Butler 
Catonsville 
Chase 
Cockeysville 
Hunt Valley 
Dundalk 
Dundalk Sparrows 
Point Essex 
Fork 
Fort Howard 
Freeland 
Garrison 
Glen Arm 
Glencoe 
Glyndon 
Granite 
Gwynn Oak 
Hereford 
Hunt Valley 
Hydes 
Kingsville 
Loch Raven 

 

Loch Raven Village 
Long Green 
Lutherville 
Lutherville Timonium 
Maryland Line 
Middle River 
Monkton 
Nottingham 
Owings Mills 
Parkton 
Parkville 
Perry Hall 
Phoenix 
Pikesville 
Randallstown 
Reisterstown
Riderwood 
Rosedale 
Ruxton 
Sparks 
Stevenson 
Timonium 
Towson 
Upper Falls 
Upperco 
White Marsh 

 

Calvert County 

Barstow 
Broomes Island 
Chesapeake Beach 
Dowell 
Dunkirk 
Huntingtown
Lusby 

 

North Beach 
Owings 
Port Republic 
Prince Frederick 
Saint Leonard 
Solomons 
Sunderland 



Caroline County 

Bethlehem 
Denton 
Federalsburg 
Goldsboro 
Greensboro 

 

Henderson 
Hillsboro 
Marydel 
Preston 
Ridgely 
Templeville



Carroll County 

Carrolltowne 
Eldersburg 
Finksburg 
Hampstead 
Henryton 
Keymar 
Lineboro 
Linwood 
Manchester 
Marriottsville

 

Millers 
New Windsor 
Sykesville 
Taneytown 
Union Bridge 
Uniontown 
Westminster 
Winfield 
Woodbine 
Woodstock

Cecil County 

Cecilton 
Charlestown 
Chesapeake City 
Childs 
Colora 
Conowingo 
Earleville 
Elk Mills 

 

Elkton 
Georgetown 
North East 
Perry Point 
Perryville 
Port Deposit 
Rising Sun 
Warwick

Charles County 

Bel Alton 
Benedict 
Bryans Road 
Bryantown 
Cobb Island 
Faulkner 
Hughesville 
Indian Head 
Ironsides 
Issue 
La Plata 

 

Marbury 
Mount Victoria 
Nanjemoy 
Newburg 
Pisgah 
Pomfret 
Port Tobacco 
Rock Point 
Waldorf 
Welcome 
White Plains

Dorchester County 

Cambridge 
Church Creek 
Crapo 
Crocheron 
East New Market 
Fishing Creek 
Hurlock 
Linkwood 

 

Rhodesdale 
Secretary 
Taylors Island 
Toddville 
Vienna 
Wingate 
Woolford

Frederick County 

Adamstown 
Braddock Heights 
Brunswick 
Buckeystown 
Burkittsville 
Emmitsburg 
Frederick 
Ijamsville 
Jefferson 
Knoxville 
Ladiesburg 
Libertytown 
Middletown 
Monrovia 

 

Mount Airy 
Myersville 
New Market 
New Midway 
Point of Rocks 
Rocky Ridge 
Sabillasville 
Thurmont 
Tuscarora 
Unionville 
Urbana 
Walkersville 
Woodsboro

Garrett County 

Accident 
Bittinger 
Bloomington 
Crellin 
Deer Park 
Friendsville 

 

Grantsville 
Kitzmiller 
McHenry 
Mountain Lake 
Park 
Oakland 
Swanton 

 

Harford County 

Aberdeen 
Abingdon 
Bel Air 
Belcamp 
Benson 
Cardiff 
Churchville 
Darlington 
Edgewood 
Fallston 

 

Forest Hill 
Gunpowder 
Havre de Grace 
Jarrettsville 
Joppa 
Magnolia 
Perryman 
Pylesville 
Street 
White Hall 
Whiteford

Howard County 

Annapolis Junction 
Clarksville 
Columbia 
Cooksville 
Dayton 
Elkridge 
Ellicott City 
Fulton 

 

Glenelg 
Glenwood 
Halethorpe 
Highland 
Jessup 
Lisbon 
Savage 
Simpsonville 
West Friendship

Kent County 

Betterton 
Galena 
Kennedyville 
Massey 

 

Millington 
Rock Hall 
Still Pond 
Worton 

Montgomery County 

Ashton 
Aspen Hill 
Barnesville 
Beallsville 
Bethesda 
Boyds 
Brinklow 
Brookeville 
Burtonsville 
Cabin John 
Chevy Chase 
Clarksburg 
Colesville 
Comus 
Damascus 
Darnestown 
Derwood 
Dickerson 
Gaithersburg 

 

Garrett Park 
Germantown 
Glen Echo 
Kensington 
Laytonsville 
Montgomery Village 
North Bethesda 
North Potomac 
Olney 
Poolesville 
Potomac 
Rockville 
Sandy Spring 
Silver Spring 
Spencerville 
Takoma Park 
Washington Grove 
West Bethesda 
Wheaton

Prince George's County 

Accokeek 
Adelphi 
Aquasco 
Beltsville 
Berwyn Heights 
Bladensburg 
Bowie 
Brandywine 
Brentwood 
Calverton 
Camp Springs 
Capitol Heights 
Cheltenham 
Cheverly 
Chillum 
Clinton 
College Park 
Cottage City 
Croom 
District Heights 
Forestville 
Fort Washington 
Glenn Dale 
Greenbelt 

 

Hyattsville 
Landover 
Landover Hills 
Langley Park 
Lanham 
Largo 
Laurel 
Marlow Heights 
Mitchellville 
Montpelier 
Morningside 
Mount Rainier 
New Carrollton 
Oxon Hill 
Riverdale 
Riverdale Park 
Seabrook 
Springdale 
Suitland 
Temple Hills 
University Park 
Upper Marlboro 
West Hyattsville

Queen Anne's County 

Centreville 
Chester 
Chestertown 
Church Hill 
Crumpton 
Grasonville 

 

Ingleside 
Price 
Queen Anne 
Queenstown 
Stevensville 
Sudlersville 

St. Mary's County 

Avenue 
Bushwood 
California 
Callaway 
Chaptico 
Charlotte Hall 
Clements 
Coltons Point 
Compton 
Dameron 
Drayden 
Great Mills 
Helen 
Hollywood 

 

Leonardtown 
Lexington Park 
Loveville 
Mechanicsville 
Morganza 
Park Hall 
Patuxent River 
Piney Point 
Ridge 
Saint Inigoes 
Saint Mary's City 
Scotland 
Tall Timbers 
Valley Lee 

Somerset County 

Chance 
Crisfield 
Dames Quarter 
Deal Island 
Ewell 
Manokin 

 

Marion Station 
Princess Anne 
Rehobeth 
Tylerton 
Upper Fairmount 
Wenona 
Westover

Talbot County 

Bozman 
Claiborne 
Cordova 
Easton 
McDaniel 
Neavitt 
Newcomb 

 

Oxford 
Royal Oak 
Saint Michaels 
Sherwood 
Tilghman 
Trappe 
Wittman 
Wye Mills

Washington County 

Big Pool 
Boonsboro 
Brownsville 
Cascade 
Cavetown 
Chewsville 
Clear Spring 
Fairplay 
Funkstown 

 

Gapland 
Hagerstown 
Hancock 
Keedysville 
Maugansville 
Rohrersville 
Saint James 
Sharpsburg 
Smithsburg 
Williamsport

Wicomico County 

Allen 
Bivalve 
Delmar 
Fruitland 
Hebron 
Mardela Springs 
Nanticoke 
Parsonsburg 

 

Pittsville 
Powellville 
Quantico 
Salisbury 
Sharptown 
Tyaskin 
Whitehaven 
Willards 

Worcester County 

Berlin 
Bishopville 
Eden 
Girdletree 
Newark 
Ocean City 

 

Ocean Pines 
Pocomoke City 
Showell 
Snow Hill 
Stockton 
Whaleyville 

"There is No Substitute For Experience."

JACK I. HYATT 
Medical Malpractice Attorney  

Attorney Profile: 
Former Assistant State's Attorney
Admitted To Practice Before:
The U.S. Supreme Court
All Maryland Courts
Federal District Court

Member:
Maryland State Bar Association 
Baltimore City Bar Association 
Baltimore County Bar Association 
University of Baltimore 
A.A. B.S. J.D. 
Honorable Discharge U.S. Army 

 
Click To E-mail For Answers To Your Questions

 

Home | Drunk Driving Questions and Answers
Privacy Policy and Disclaimer | Contact Us | Links